Mystery Theatre by the Season
Season 1: July 1996-June 1997
July “Speakeasy, Die Hard”
August “Speakeasy, Die Hard”
September “Take Me Out of the Ball Game”
October “Take Me Out of the Ball Game”
November “Slay Ride: Rudolph the Dead-Nosed Reindeer”
December “Slay Ride: Rudolph the Dead-Nosed Reindeer”
January “Variety Is the Spice of Death”
February “Variety Is the Spice of Death”
March “A Medium for Murder”
April “A Medium for Murder”
May “Happiness is a Warm Gun”
June “Happiness is a Warm Gun”
Season 2: July 1997-June 1998
July “Recipe for Murder”
August “Recipe for Murder”
September “Montana Marie Gets Gunned Down at Three”
October “Montana Marie Gets Gunned Down at Three”
November “Slay Ride: Rudolph the Dead-Nosed Reindeer” (revival)
December “Slay Ride: Rudolph the Dead-Nosed Reindeer” (revival)
January “Salon, Farewell, Aufweidersen, You’re Dead”
February “Salon, Farewell, Aufweidersen, You’re Dead”
March “Salon, Farewell, Aufweidersen, You’re Dead”
April “Il Mote di Figaro”
May “Il Mote di Figaro”
June “Il Mote di Figaro”
Season 3: July 1998-June 1999
July “The Case of the Ditz and the Diamond”
August “The Case of the Ditz and the Diamond”
September “You Bet You’re Jurassic He’s Dead”
October “You Bet You’re Jurassic He’s Dead”
November “Slay Ride II: Screaming All the Way”
December “Slay Ride II: Screaming All the Way”
January “Avast! Ye Murderous Swabs”
February “Avast! Ye Murderous Swabs”
March “Avast! Ye Murderous Swabs”
April “The Tragic Death of Alfred the Squatty”
May “The Tragic Death of Alfred the Squatty”
June “The Tragic Death of Alfred the Squatty”
Season 4: July 1999-June 2000
July “Variety Is the Spice of Death” (revival)
August “The Case of the Ms. and the Show Biz Whiz”
September “The Case of the Ms. and the Show Biz Whiz”
October “The Case of the Ms. and the Show Biz Whiz”
November “DOA in the Y2K”
December “DOA in the Y2K”
January “Damn! Damn! That Rotten Old Nottingham”
February “Damn! Damn! That Rotten Old Nottingham”
March “Damn! Damn! That Rotten Old Nottingham”
April “License to Spy”
May “License to Spy”
June “License to Spy”
Season 5: July 2000-June 2001
July “Who Wants to Murder a Millionaire?”
August “Who Wants to Murder a Millionaire?”
September “Who Wants to Murder a Millionaire?”
October “Something Stinks at P.U.”
November “Slay Ride I” (revival) and “Slay Ride II” (revival)
December “Slay Ride I” (revival) and “Slay Ride II” (revival)
January “Space Trek”
February “Space Trek”
March “Space Trek”
April “The Menace of the Super-Duper Party Pooper”
May “The Menace of the Super-Duper Party Pooper”
June “The Menace of the Super-Duper Party Pooper”
Season 6: July 2001-June 2002
July “Once Upon a Crime”
August "Once Upon a Crime”
September “Once Upon a Crime”
October “Once Upon a Crime”
November “Slay Ride III: The Santa Sham Scam”
December “Slay Ride III: The Santa Sham Scam”
January [hiatus]
February “Survivor on Killigan’s Island”
March “Survivor on Killigan’s Island”
April “Survivor on Killigan’s Island”
May “One Life to Lose”
June “One Life to Lose”
Season 7: July 2002-June 2003
July “One Life to Lose”
August “Space Trek” (revival)
September “Space Trek” (revival)
October “Space Trek” (revival)
November “Slay Ride III: The Santa Sham Scam” (revival)
December “Slay Ride III: The Santa Sham Scam” (revival)
January [hiatus]
February “E.A.T. The Extra Added Terrestrial”
March “E.A.T. The Extra Added Terrestrial”
April “E.A.T. The Extra Added Terrestrial”
May “Indiana Smith and the Restaurant of Doom”
June “Indiana Smith and the Restaurant of Doom”
Season 8: July 2003-June 2004
July “Indiana Smith and the Restaurant of Doom”
August “Tales from the Script”
September “Tales from the Script”
October “Tales from the Script”
November “Slay Ride IV: Revenge of the Claus”
December “Slay Ride IV: Revenge of the Claus”
January [hiatus]
February “Once Upon a Crime” (revival)
March “Once Upon a Crime” (revival)
April “Once Upon a Crime” (revival)
May “Murder on the Luv Boat”
June “Murder on the Luv Boat”
Season 9: July 2004-June 2005
July “Murder on the Luv Boat”
August “The Capitol Hillbillies”
September “The Capitol Hillbillies”
October “The Capitol Hillbillies”
November “Slay Ride IV: Revenge of the Claus” (revival)
December “Slay Ride IV: Revenge of the Claus” (revival)
January [hiatus]
February “The Case of the Ditz and the Diamond” (revival)
March “The Case of the Ditz and the Diamond” (revival)
April “The Case of the Ditz and the Diamond” (revival)
May “The Maltese Ferret”
June “The Maltese Ferret”
Season 10: July 2005-June 2006
July “The Maltese Ferret”
August “Murder Under the Big Top”
September “Murder Under the Big Top”
October “Murder Under the Big Top”
November “Slay Ride V – CSI: North Pole”
December “Slay Ride V – CSI: North Pole”
January “Murder on the Luv Boat” (revival)
February “Indiana Smith and the Restaurant of Doom” (revival)
March “Murder at the Kit Kat Klub”
April “Space Trek” (revival)
May “Murder at the Kit Kat Klub”
June “Murder at the Kit Kat Klub”
Season 11: July 2006-June 2007
July “The Menace of the Super-Duper Party Pooper”
August “The Menace of the Super-Duper Party Pooper”
September “The Wizard of Odds”
October “The Wizard of Odds”
November “The Wizard of Odds”
December “The Wizard of Odds”
January “I Killed Lucy”
February “I Killed Lucy”
March “I Killed Lucy”
April “McDeath" or "Nothing Much About Doo-Doo”
May “McDeath" or "Nothing Much About Doo-Doo”
June “McDeath" or "Nothing Much About Doo-Doo”
Season 12: July 2007-June 2008
July “The Capitol Hillbillies” (revival)
August “The Capitol Hillbillies” (revival)
September “Indiana Smith and the Restaurant of Doom” (revival)
October “You’re a Dead Man, Chuckie Brown”
November “You’re a Dead Man, Chuckie Brown”
December “Slay Ride V – CSI: North Pole” (revival)
January “Once Upon a Crime” (revival)
February “Murder on the Luv Boat” (revival)
March “Murder on the Luv Boat” (revival)
April “Kill Phil”
May “Kill Phil”
June “The Wizard of Odds” (revival)
Season 13: July 2008-June 2009
July “The Wizard of Odds” (revival)
August “Murder at the Kit Kat Klub” (revival)
September “Indiana Smith and the Raiders of the Lost Sequel”
October “Indiana Smith and the Raiders of the Lost Sequel”
November “Slay Ride IV: Revenge of the Claus” (revival)
December “Slay Ride IV: Revenge of the Claus” (revival)
January “One Life to Lose”
February “One Life to Lose”
March “I Killed Lucy” (revival)
April “I Killed Lucy” (revival)
May “Coleslaw and Order”
June “Coleslaw and Order”
Season 14: July 2009-June 2010
July “McDeath" or "Nothing Much About Doo-Doo” (revival)
August “McDeath" or "Nothing Much About Doo-Doo” (revival)
September “Mind Over Murder”
October “Mind Over Murder”
November “Mind Over Murder”
December “Slay Ride III: The Santa Sham Scam” (revival)
January “Murder Under the Big Top” (revival)
February “Murder Under the Big Top” (revival)
March “Mayberry R.I.P.”
April “Mayberry R.I.P.”
May “Salon, Farewell, Aufweidersen, You’re Dead” (revival)
June “Salon, Farewell, Aufweidersen, You’re Dead” (revival)
Season 15: July 2010-June 2011
July [hiatus]
August “The Wizard of Odds” (revival)
September “Rock ‘em Dead”
October “Rock ‘em Dead”
November “Slay Ride VI: Santa’s Last Christmas”
December “Slay Ride VI: Santa’s Last Christmas”
January “Kill Phil”
February “Kill Phil”
March “Kill Phil”
April “Pirates of Poughkeepsie”
May “Pirates of Poughkeepsie”
June “Once Upon a Crime” (revival)
Season 16: July 2011-June 2012
July “Once Upon a Crime” (revival)
August “Once Upon a Crime” (revival)
September “Dr. Jackal and Mr. Hype”
October “Dr. Jackal and Mr. Hype”
November “A Deadly Christmas Carol”
December “A Deadly Christmas Carol”
January “The Maltese Ferret” (revival)
February “The Maltese Ferret” (revival)
March “Who Killed the Top Chef?”
April “Who Killed the Top Chef?”
May “Indiana Smith and the Raiders of the Lost Sequel” (revival)
June “Indiana Smith and the Raiders of the Lost Sequel” (revival)
Season 17: July 2012-June 2013
July “Indiana Smith and the Raiders of the Lost Sequel” (revival)
August “Indiana Smith and the Raiders of the Lost Sequel” (revival)
September “Coleslaw and Order” (revival)
October “Coleslaw and Order” (revival)
November “Slay Ride II: Screaming All the Way” (revival)
December “Slay Ride II: Screaming All the Way” (revival)
January “Mission: Unpossible”
February “Mission: Unpossible”
March “Dead of the Class”
April “Dead of the Class”
May “Dead of the Class”
June “Mayberry R.I.P.” (revival)
Season 18: July 2013-June 2014
July “Mayberry R.I.P.” (revival)
August “Mayberry R.I.P.” (revival)
September “Calamityville Horror”
October “Calamityville Horror”
November “Slay Ride IV: Revenge of the Claus” (revival)
December “Slay Ride IV: Revenge of the Claus” (revival)
January “Mind Over Murder” (revival)
February “Mind Over Murder” (revival)
March “Overture for an Undertaker”
April “Overture for an Undertaker”
May “Overture for an Undertaker”
June “Pirates of Poughkeepsie” (revival)
Season 19: July 2014-June 2015
July “Pirates of Poughkeepsie” (revival)
August “Pirates of Poughkeepsie” (revival)
September “How the West Was Dumb”
October “How the West Was Dumb”
November “Slay Ride V – CSI: North Pole” (revival)
December “Slay Ride V – CSI: North Pole” (revival)
January “Survivor on Killigan’s Island” (revival)
February “Survivor on Killigan’s Island” (revival)
March “McDeath" or "Nothing Much About Doo-Doo” (revival)
April “Happily Never After”
May “Happily Never After”
June “Happily Never After”/”McDeath” (revival)
Season 20: July 2015-June 2016
July “Mayberry R.I.P.” (revival)
August [hiatus]
September “Johnny B. Dead”
October “Johnny B. Dead”
November “Johnny B. Dead”
December “Slay Ride VI: Santa’s Last Christmas” (revival)
January “The Capitol Hillbillies” (revival)
February “The Capitol Hillbillies” (revival)
March “The Capitol Hillbillies” (revival)
April “Star Bores”
May “Star Bores”
June “Star Bores”
Season 21: July 2016-June 2017
July “Star Bores”
August [hiatus]
September “Dead of State”
October “Dead of State”
November“Dead of State”/“A Deadly Christmas Carol”
December “A Deadly Christmas Carol” (revival)
January “Space Trek” (revival)
February “Space Trek” (revival)
March “Space Trek” (revival)
April “My Big Fat Reality Wedding”
May “My Big Fat Reality Wedding”
June “My Big Fat Reality Wedding”
Season 22: July 2017-June 2018
July “Dr. Jackal and Mr. Hype” (revival)
August “My Big Fat Reality Wedding”
September “My Big Fat Reality Wedding”
October “Last Kill and Testament”
November “Last Kill and Testament”
December “Slay Ride: Rudolph the Dead-Nosed Reindeer” (revival)
January “Murder on the Luv Boat”
February “Murder on the Luv Boat”
March “Murder on the Luv Boat”
April “Murder at the Kit Kat Klub” (revival)
May “Murder at the Kit Kat Klub” (revival)
June “Murder at the Kit Kat Klub” (revival)
Season 23: July 2018-June 2019
July “Murder at the Kit Kat Klub” (revival)
August “Murder at the Kit Kat Klub” (revival)
September “One Life to Lose” (revival)
October “One Life to Lose” (revival)
November “One Life to Lose” (revival)
December “One Life to Lose” (revival)
January “Rock ‘em Dead” (revival)
February “Rock ‘em Dead” (revival)
March “Rock ‘em Dead” (revival)
April “The Case of the Ms. and the Show Biz Whiz” (revival)
May “The Case of the Ms. and the Show Biz Whiz” (revival)
June “The Case of the Ms. and the Show Biz Whiz” (revival)
Season 24: July 2017-June 2018
July “The Case of the Ms. and the Show Biz Whiz” (revival)
August “The Case of the Ms. and the Show Biz Whiz” (revival)
September “Popguy the Sailor”
October “Popguy the Sailor”
November “Popguy the Sailor”
December “Slay Ride II: Screaming All the Way” (revival)
January “Popguy the Sailor”
February “Popguy the Sailor”
March [COVID hiatus]
April [COVID hiatus]
May [COVID hiatus]
June [COVID hiatus]
Season 25: July 2020-June 2021
July [COVID hiatus]
August [COVID hiatus]
September [COVID hiatus]
October [COVID hiatus]
November [COVID hiatus]
December [COVID hiatus]
January [COVID hiatus]
February [COVID hiatus]
March [COVID hiatus]
April [COVID hiatus]
May [COVID hiatus]
June “How the West Was Dumb” (revival)
Season 26: July 2021-June 2022
July “How the West Was Dumb” (revival)
August “How the West Was Dumb” (revival)
September “Johnny B. Dead” (revival)
October “Johnny B. Dead” (revival)
November “Johnny B. Dead” (revival)
December “Slay Ride IV: Revenge of the Claus” (revival)
January “Indiana Smith and the Restaurant of Doom” (revival)
February “Indiana Smith and the Restaurant of Doom” (revival)
March “Indiana Smith and the Restaurant of Doom” (revival)
April “Mind Over Murder” (revival)
May “Mind Over Murder” (revival)
June “Mind Over Murder” (revival)
Season 27: July 2022-June 2023
July “Mind Over Murder” (revival)
August “Mind Over Murder” (revival)
September “The Wizard of Odds” (revival)
October “The Wizard of Odds” (revival)
November “The Wizard of Odds” (revival)
December “A Very Hellmark Christmas Special”
January “Happily Never After” (revival)
February “Happily Never After” (revival)
March “Happily Never After” (revival)
April “Mission: Unpossible” (revival)
May “Mission: Unpossible” (revival)
June “Mission: Unpossible” (revival)
Season 28: July 2023-June 2024
July “Indiana Smith and the Raiders of the Lost Sequel” (revival)
August “Indiana Smith and the Raiders of the Lost Sequel” (revival)
September “The Maltese Ferret” (revival)
October “The Maltese Ferret” (revival)
November “The Maltese Ferret” (revival)
December “Slay Ride V – CSI: North Pole” (revival)
January “Bridgerdon Abbey”
February “Bridgerdon Abbey”
March “Bridgerdon Abbey”
April “Overture for an Undertaker” (revival)
May “Overture for an Undertaker” (revival)
June “Overture for an Undertaker” (revival)
Mystery Theatre by Title | Mystery Theatre by Show Theme | Back to Shows
Home | Now Playing! | Next Production | Frequently Asked Questions | About the Actors | Mystery History | Videos | Shows
Audience Photos | Whodunnit? | Drag Characters | Links | Booking Info | Venue Directions | Why We're Special | Backstage | Email Us
Private Parties Call:
304-280-8681
Last updated: December 18, 2023