The Mystery Theatre Unlimited Cast

The Mystery Theatre Unlimited Company

Mystery Theatre Unlimited company group photo

Our current cast

Sean Decker • Dustin Heavilin • Butch Maxwell • Renee Storm • Micah Underwood
Sean Decker Dustin Heavilin Butch Maxwell Renee Storm Micah Underwood

Other members of our ensemble

Vera Barton-Maxwell • Josh DeBeni • Sadie Crow Vargas • Pete Fernbaugh • Karissa Martin • Melody Meadows • Joel Nau
Vera Barton-Maxwell Sadie Crow Vargas Pete Fernbaugh Karissa Martin Melody Meadows Joel Nau

Emeritus members of the company

Gino Angelo Vera Barton-Maxwell Cheryl Burke Bert Furioli Dee (McCorkle) Gregg Michael Moran Arlene Merryman Ryan Sears Frank Wilson

Other people who have appeared with us

Kathy Barton Josh DeBeni Sean Decker Kevin Dennis Jim Ellis Pete Fernbaugh Deborah Frazier P.D. Gregg Jenn Kellner Muscar Mario Muscar Shannan Noe Evan Oslund Rachel Podwika Thompson Michael Ramsay John Reilly Gretchen Schneider Maura Schneider Brenden Sheehen Valery Staskey Cheryl Violette

Last updated: September 9, 2025